How to Find the Perfect Gift for Your Partner (Without Overthinking It)

Gift shopping for your partner can feel like a high-stakes guessing game—especially if you want to find something they’ll truly love. But here’s the secret: the clues are already in front of you.

If you’re stuck on what to get, try this approach. It’s simple, thoughtful, and (best of all) helps you avoid the “Oh… thanks?” reaction.

Start With What You Know

Think about what your partner has been into lately. Have they made any big style changes? A new haircut might mean they’d love statement earrings. If they’ve been wearing more rings, maybe a unique handmade piece would be perfect.

Gift Ideas:

• For the Jewelry Lover: Consider this silver necklace from Verso jewelry. This delicate piece combines elegance with a touch of color, making it a versatile addition to any wardrobe.

Shown above: 

Necklace - Small Silver Laurel (Lavender) by Verso

• For the Earring Enthusiast: Our Cloud Earrings by Chickenscratch are whimsical yet sophisticated, perfect for someone who appreciates unique accessories handmade by experienced craftspeople.

What about their interests? Do they always have a candle burning? Love a good artisan chocolate bar? Even the small things they use every day can spark a great gift idea.

Gift Ideas:

• For the Candle Lover: Our collection of candles such as this Sea Salt & Orchid Candle by Cedar Street Co. offers an elegant aromatic blend of delicate tropical floral notes with sweet and salty highlights.

• For the Chocolate Aficionado: Indulge their sweet tooth with one of our Assortments of Chocolate BonBons by Dolcetta Artisan Sweets, featuring an array of delectable flavors.

Pay Attention to the Little Moments

Ever noticed what makes their eyes light up? That’s a gift-giving goldmine. Maybe they geek out over beautifully made accessories, unique home goods, or anything with a fun, artistic touch.

If you’re really unsure, try bringing up things you see online. “Hey, what do you think of this?” Casual conversations can give you a sense of their taste—without ruining the surprise.

Gift Ideas:

• For the Home Decor Enthusiast: We have many handmade home decor items to choose from that add a personal touch to any room. Our Hanging Himmeli by Hemleva gives a modern, minimalist vibe to any space and can hold an air plant or stand alone as a geometric ornament.

Shown above:

Home Decor - The Teardrop Hanging Himmeli by Hemleva

• For the Accessory Admirer: If your sweetheart likes to travel, then the Tall Zippered Toiletry Bag in Black by Hold Supply Company is both practical and stylish, ideal for life-on-the-go or daily use.

High Fashion or Thrift Store Treasure Hunter?

Your partner’s shopping style can also guide you. If they love one-of-a-kind finds, they’ll appreciate something handmade and full of character. If they lean toward sleek, modern aesthetics, minimalist jewelry or a stylish travel bag could be the way to go.

Gift Ideas:

• For the Vintage Lover: Altered Relics Jewelry by Christine Stoll are a unique line of handmade pieces that feature vintage rhinestones, watch dials, Victorian-era illustrations, and trinkets, offering a unique blend of history and style.

• For the Modern Minimalist: For a rustic design that still holds functional elegance, we have the Bees on Honeycomb Ceramic Mug by White Squirrel Clayworks, making that morning brew a memorable experience for the nature-lover.

Think About Past Wins

What was the most successful gift you’ve given them? What did they love about it? If you nailed it last year, a fresh take on that category could be a safe bet. If you missed the mark, now’s your chance to course-correct.

Gift Ideas:

• If They Loved Cozy Comforts: Try the Peppermint Hot Chocolate Mix by Creekside Mallow Co. for a delightful blend of rich cocoa and refreshing peppermint, perfect for a cozy evening.

• If They Appreciated Nature-Inspired Goods: The Roots Walnut Plant Stand by 6 by 6 combines functionality with artistic design, making it a unique and thoughtful gift.

No Stress, No Pressure

Worried about getting it just right? We’ve got you. Our 30-day return policy means your partner can easily exchange their gift if they want something different. (Check out our exchange policy here for the details.)

At the end of the day, a great gift isn’t just about the item—it’s about showing you notice and appreciate them. With a little attention to their everyday favorites, you’ll find something that feels just right.

Ready to start shopping? Browse our favorite gifts for them here.